You have skipped the navigation, tab for page content
1975 - Simply The Best

After an extraordinary year for the Eastern Suburbs Roosters in 1974, the chances of the club replicating that success in 1975 was truly wishful thinking. 

To recall, the 1974 Roosters:

  • Won the Club’s first First Grade premiership in 29 years, defeating Canterbury-Bankstown 19-4 in the Grand Final 
  • Won the First Grade minor premiership by 8 points 
  • Won the Club Championship by 67 points 
  • Won the Pre-Season Cup Final 
  • Were runners-up in both the Reserve Grade minor premiership and premiership 
  • Were defeated semi-finalists in the Under 23s competition 

The Roosters’ biggest obstacle was the introduction of the 13 Import Rule, which would remain for nine seasons. The 13 Import Rule meant that only 13 players who had not played at least two seasons of junior rugby league with their club could be contracted to play in any of the three senior grades per season. 

Given the Roosters had 36 imports in 1974, 24 of whom played First Grade, not even the most optimistic fan would have believed the club could replace at least 23 players and expect to have sufficient depth to defend their First Grade and Club Championship titles. 

However, the Roosters did in fact replicate their success in 1975 by: 

  • Again, winning the First Grade premiership, famously defeating St George 38-0 in the Grand Final (when tries were worth 3 points only) 
  • Winning the First Grade minor premiership by a whopping 10 points 
  • Setting a competition record of 19 successive First Grade premiership wins 
  • Reaching the second week of finals in both Reserve Grade and Under 23s 
  • Winning the Mid-Season Cup Final 
  • Winning a second successive Club Championship (this time by 53 points)

Plenty has been written about the extraordinary 1975 Roosters First Grade team and their achievements, but this article aims to focus on the unbelievable Roosters’ Club Championship success, in light of the introduction of the 13 Import Rule. 

The Club Championship was introduced in 1930 and until 1997 was based on the performances of each Club’s three senior grades. First Grade premiership points were multiplied by four, Reserve Grade (Second Grade) points were multiplied by three and Under 23s/Third Grade points were multiplied by two. 

The Roosters had great success in the early years of the Club Championship, winning it 7 times in its first 16 seasons but didn’t win it between 1946 and 1969. It won in 1970 and again in 1974, the Club’s ninth Club Championship. 

Trying to hold on to their best players for the 1975 season was particularly difficult. In light of the success of the 1974 Roosters, naturally many rival clubs targeted several stars and those who couldn’t hold down a regular First Grade spot. But it wasn’t only players who were poached. 

Terry Fearnley, one of the Roosters great clubmen of the 1950s and 1960s was Jack Gibson’s right-hand man in 1974, but Parramatta had earmarked him as Norm Provan’s long-term replacement as First Grade coach and he left for the Eels at the end of 1974. However, Parramatta weren’t just satisfied with luring Fearnley. They went after all four Roosters premiership three-quarters (Jim Porter, John Brass, Mark Harris and Bill Mullins). They picked up Porter but missed the other three after Brass knocked them back, which ensured Harris and Mullins stayed as well. The Eels did pick up two members of the Roosters Reserve Grade Grand Final team in centre Ray Strudwick and second-rower Graham Olling. Porter and Olling would go on and play for Australia from the Eels. 

In total, 18 players with First Grade experience that were at the Roosters in 1974, left the club. 

Departing 1974 Roosters imports with First Grade experience at the Club

Player Roosters Years (all grades) 1975 Destination
Jim Porter * 1970 - 1974  Parramatta
Graham Olling 1972 - 1974  Parramatta
Ray Strudwick 1973 - 1974  Parramatta
Ian Baker 1970 - 1974  Manly-Warringah
Laurier Freier 1970 - 1974  Manly-Warringah
Allan McKean ^ 1967 - 1974  St George 
John Dykes  1970 - 1974  South Sydney 
Doug Lucas 1974 - 1974  Newtown 
Harry Cameron * 1971 - 1974  Wests, Brisbane 
Kel Brown ^ 1971 - 1974  Wests, Brisbane 
John Armstrong ^ 1972 - 1974  Wests, Brisbane 
Pat Kelly  1973 - 1974  Wests, Brisbane 
Greg McCarthy 1974 - 1974  Wests, Brisbane 
Arthur Mountier < 1974 - 1974  Dapto, NSW 
Terry Stevens  1973 - 1974  Wests, Newcastle
Kerry Collien ^  1973 - 1974  Gundagai, NSW 
Mick Alchin ^  1972 - 1974  Wentworthville, NSW
Mick Souter >  1974 - 1974  Early Retirement 

* Played in the 1974 Roosters First Grade Grand Final winning team 
^ Didn't play a First Grade premiership match at the Roosters In 1974 
> Became a trainer with the Roosters in 1975 
< Re-joined the Roosters as an import for the 1979-80 seasons 

Apart from those who departed for Parramatta, others to leave included Allan McKean, the former Australian international who was to hold the Roosters point scoring record for 33 years, former NSW hooker Kel Brown and 1974 Roosters premiership winner Harry Cameron. Brown and Cameron were two of five Roosters players to join the Wests Panthers in Brisbane. Under Cameron’s captaincy, the Panthers won the 1975 Brisbane premiership. Both Cameron and Greg McCarthy would go on to play for Queensland.

Another nine imports who had to play First Grade at the Roosters were also shown the door. Among those was Steve Bullow, who would also represent Queensland in the 1970s. 

Other departing imports who played at the Roosters in 1974 

Player Roosters Years (all grades) 1975 Destination
Rick McCarthy 1972 - 1974  Wests, Newcastle
Steve Bullow  1973 - 1974  Redcliffe, Queensland
Geoff Cahill  1973 - 1974  Bondi Sharks 
Graham Morrisey 1973 - 1974  Gulgong, NSW 
Bill Hilliard  1974 - 1974  University Of NSW 
Brad Marshall  1974 - 1974   
Jim McMullen  1974 - 1974  Wauchope 
Glenn Phillips  1974 - 1974   

Those 26 departing imports were joined by a further 13 non-imports who did not return for the 1975 season. 

Other 1974 Roosters who didn't return for the 1975 season

Player Junior Club Roosters Years (all grades) 1975 Destination
Sam Galpern Paddington Colts 1972 - 1974 Retired
Peter Nunan  Denison Hotel 1972 - 1974 Kempsey, NSW 
Greg White ^ Waverley Dolphins 1974 - 1974  Waverley Dolphins
Daryl Gear  Denison Hotel  1974 - 1974  Work Commitments
Peter Lakeman   1974 - 1974   
Dick Wells  Bondi United  1974 - 1974  Coogee
Keith Peime  Bondi United  1974 - 1974  Passed Away (Fiji)
Bob Hooper  Clovelly  1974 - 1974  Clovelly 
Stuart Kelly *  Double Bay  1974 - 1974  Double Bay
Jimmy Hassan Paddington-Woollahra RSL 1974 - 1974  Maroubra 
Wayne Currall # Alexandria Rovers 1974 - 1974  South Sydney
D. Hoban   1974 - 1974   
O. Iwanow   1974 - 1974   

With only 13 imports allowed the Roosters needed to find up to three dozen players to grade from the Roosters junior ranks. The imports retained totalled 10, including eight 1974 premiership players plus Kevin Stevens and Bruce Pickett. 

1974 Roosters imports retained for the 1975 season

Player Roosters Years (all grades) Junior District
Mark Harris 1970 - 1979  Brisbane, Queensland
Arthur Beetson 1971 - 1978  Roma, Queensland 
Greg Bandiera *^ 1972 - 1975  Innisfail, Queensland
John Brass 1969 - 1976  Randwick Rugby Union
Russell Fairfax 1974 - 1980  Randwick Rugby Union
Bill Mullins  1968 - 1978  Canterbury-Bankstown
Ron Coote  1972 - 1978  South Sydney 
Kevin Stevens  1973 - 1980  South Grafton 
Bruce Pickett  1974 - 1977  Newtown 
Elwyn Walters  1974 - 1976  Tweed Heads, NSW

* Didn't play a First Grade premiership match at the Roosters in 1973 
^ Replaced as an import by Peter Fitzgerald (Canowindra, NSW) for the 1976 season 

The Roosters also had contracted four other imports to join the Club for the 1975 season. Unfortunately, for future NSW five eighth Robert Laurie, he was unable to play in any grade for the Roosters in 1975 as he would have been the 14th import. He played the 1975 season with the Paddington Colts club in the Easts juniors and played Presidents Cup that year for the Club. 

Imports recruited for the 1975 season

Player Roosters Years (all grades) Junior District
Dennis Tutty > 1975 - 1975  Balmain 
John Cole *< 1975 - 1975  Randwick Rugby Union
Ian Schubert  1975 - 1980, 1982  Wauchope, NSW 
Robert Laurie ^ 1976 - 1977, 1981 - 1982  Wauchope, NSW 

* Didn't play a First Grade premiership match at the Roosters 
^ Played the 1975 season with Paddington Colts due to the 13 Import Rule 
> Replaced as an import by Royce Ayliffe (Wollongong, NSW) for the 1976 season 
< Replaced as an import by Robert Laurie (Wauchope, NSW) for the 1976 season 

The search to fill the other roster spots with Roosters juniors commenced with the retention of 20 men who played for the Club in 1974.

1974 Roosters juniors retained for 1975

Player Roosters Years (all grades) Junior Club
John Peard 1965 - 1971, 1974 - 1975  Bondi United
Les Hayes  1965 - 1975  Bondi United
Johnny Mayes 1966 - 1972, 1974 - 1977  Bondi United
Ken Jones  1971 - 1976  Bondi United
John Rheinberger ^ 1974 - 1976  Bondi United
Grant Beardmore * 1974 - 1975  Bondi United
Geoff Peard *  1974 - 1975  Bondi United
Barry 'Bunny' Reilly 1966 - 1971, 1973 - 1979  Paddington Colts
Ian Mackay  1971 - 1976  Paddington Colts
John Ferguson *  1972, 1974 - 1975  Paddington Colts
Greg Townsend ^ 1974 - 1978  Paddington Colts
Bill Markou ^  1974 - 1978  Paddington Colts
Ron Pomering *  1974 - 1976  Paddington Colts
Mick Kelly *  1974 - 1975  Paddington Colts
Mick Field ^  1974 - 1975  Paddington Colts
Bob Carnie *  1974 - 1975  Paddington Colts
Eric Ferguson <  1972 - 1977  Paddington-Woollahra RSL
Bob Farrugia ^  1974 - 1977  Catholic Club
Des O'Reilly ^  1974 - 1982  Clovelly 
Kel Sherry ^>  1972 - 1975, 1977, 1980 - 1981  Denison Hotel 

* Did not play a First Grade premiership game during his Roosters career 
^ Made his Roosters First Grade debut in 1975 
< Yenda junior who qualified as a Roosters junior by playing two seasons in the Easts juniors 
> Murwillumbah junior who qualified as a Roosters junior by playing two seasons in the Easts juniors 

Five of those 20 juniors (John Peard, Jonny Mayes, Ken Jones, Ian Mackay and Barry ‘Bunny’ Reilly’) were 1974 First Grade premiership players whilst three other juniors (Kel Sherry, Eric Ferguson and Les Hayes) had played for the Roosters in the 1974 Reserve Grade Grand Final. 

The next step was to recall as many juniors as possible who were either playing at other clubs or had returned to the junior league. Even players such as Dennis Hughes and Peter Moscatt, who had retired, were brought back to the club for the 1975 season to help fill a three-grade roster. Hughes had last played with the Roosters in 1968. Another junior, Bruce Ayshford, returned to the junior league in 1970 and surely could never have thought that five years later he’d be recalled to grade. Moscatt, Hughes and Ayshford all played First Grade in 1975, whilst Grant Hedger, who returned to the junior league after the 1973 season, would feature in the Grand Final run on side. 

Roosters juniors who returned to the Club in 1975

Player Roosters Junior Club First Roosters Stint 
(all grades)
1974 Destination  Second Roosters Stint 
(all grades)
Peter Moscatt Bondi United 1962 - 1963, 1969 - 1973  Retirement 1975 - 1975
Dennis Hughes < Bondi United 1965 - 1968  Retirement 1975 - 1975
Trevor Barnes >< Bondi United 1971 - 1972  South Sydney 1975 - 1977
Grant Hedger ^< Bondi United 1972 - 1973  Bondi United 1975 - 1979
Terry Keen * Bondi United 1973 - 1973  Woy Woy 1975 - 1978 
Paul Cross * Clovelly  1964 - 1965  Balmain 1975 - 1976 
Mark Cohen < Clovelly  1970 - 1971  Parramatta 1975 - 1975 
Bruce Ayshford Paddington Colts 1967 - 1970  Paddington Colts 1975 - 1975 
Bert Zara Paddington Colts 1969 - 1972  Paddington Colts 1975 - 1975 

^ Was a starting player in the 1975 Roosters First Grade premiership team 
* Didn't play a First Grade premiership match at the Roosters in 1975 
> Didn't play a First Grade premiership match at South Sydney in 1974 
< Made his Roosters First Grade debut in 1975 

Only two Roosters juniors remained at other clubs and one (Peter Reed) could be classified by South Sydney as a junior due to a recent arrangement that the governing body had brought in. A player who hadn’t previously played a premiership match in any grade but was a junior at a neighbouring club could play grade at the neighbouring club as a non-import. South Sydney and Eastern Suburbs were classified as neighbours for this purpose, as were Parramatta and Penrith, Cronulla-Sutherland and St George, Newtown and Canterbury-Bankstown, Balmain and Western Suburbs and Manly-Warringah and North Sydney.

Roosters juniors playing grade elsewhere in 1975 

Player Roosters Junior Club Roosters Years 
(all grades)
1975 Club Years Away From The 
Roosters (all grades)
Kevin Junee Bondi United 1962 - 1973, 1976 Manly-Warringah 1973 - 1974
Peter Reed ^ Clovelly 1976 - 1977, 1980 South Sydney 1974 - 1975, 1978 - 1979

^ Under the 13 Import Rule, Roosters juniors could play for Souths and not be classified as an import as long as they had not previously played a game in any grade at the Roosters or any other club 

The final piece of the puzzle was to introduce into the lower grades a further two dozen juniors, a record number that will never be beaten, who would go on to play Reserve Grade and Under 23s in 1975. Three of those 24 (Ray Cupic, Garry Hardaker and Reg Clough) would also go on to play First Grade in 1975 and three more (Gary Metcalfe, Michael Mosman and Michael Windeatt) would play First Grade in 1976. Metcalfe and Mosman had substantial First Grade careers at the Roosters. The expectations on these players were not high but the Club Championship was won in 1975 because so many were able to take the monumental step from junior league to senior grade. 

Juniors graded at the Roosters in 1975

Player Junior Club Roosters Years (all grades)
Michael Windeatt ^ Bondi United 1975 - 1977, 1980 - 1981
Ray Cupic *  Bondi United 1975 - 1976 
John Malone  Bondi United 1975 - 1976 
Len Fuda  Bondi United 1975 - 1975 
Jim Henney  Bondi United 1975 - 1975 
Steve Hill  Bondi United 1975 - 1975 
Vince McKell  Bondi United 1975 - 1975 
Alan Opera  Bondi United 1975 - 1975 
Denis Williams  Bondi United 1975 - 1975 
Garry Hardaker * Paddington Colts 1975 - 1977 
Mick Attard  Paddington Colts 1975 - 1975 
Mark Lord  Paddington Colts 1975 - 1975 
Gary Metcalfe ^ Bondi Royals  1975 - 1980 
Reg Clough *  Bondi Royals  1975 - 1975 
Michael Mosman ^  Clovelly  1975 - 1980 
Ray Jones  Clovelly  1975 - 1977 
Phil Jacobson  Fitzroy Hotel  1975 - 1976 
John Smith  Fitzroy Hotel  1975 - 1975 
Bruce Martin  Exchange Hotel 1975 - 1975 
Jamie Griffiths <  Mascot  1975 - 1975 
Geoff Martin <  Maroubra 1975 - 1975 
George Yacoub    1975 - 1975 
Tony McKenzie    1975 - 1975 
A. Davidson    1975 - 1975 

* Made his Roosters First Grade debut in 1975 
^ Made his Roosters First Grade debut in 1976 
< Under the 13 Import Rule Souths Juniors could play for Easts and not 
be classified as an import as long as they had not previously played 
a game in any grade at the Rabbitohs or any other club 

It was an extraordinary turnover of players and coaches. Not only did Fearnley depart, but also lower grade coach Stan Bottles, replaced by Noel Thornton and Billy Anderson. 

The constant was Head Coach Jack Gibson and a number of club greats determined to win another title. Gibson was unique in those days in having all three grades train together and had great success winning Club Championships. In 1971 as Head Coach at St George he guided the Dragons to the Club Championship and Gibson did it again at Newtown in 1973 before back-to-back success with the Roosters in 1974 and 1975. He would later lead Parramatta to Club Championship success in 1981 and 1982. 

1975 Roosters Club Championship squad photo errors 

Photo Caption Correct Name
Denis Tutty Dennis Tutty
Michael Mossman Michael Mosman
Bruce Ashford Bruce Ayshford 
Gary Hardaker  Garry Hardaker 
Lew Fuda  Len Fuda 
Denis Hughes  Dennis Hughes
John Griffiths  Jamie Griffiths 
Peter Jacobsen  Phil Jacobson

1975 Roosters Club Championship missing squad members in photo

Ron Coote Mark Lord
Greg Bandiera Vince McKell
Ian Mackay  Alan Opera
Reg Clough  John Smith
Mick Field  Jim Henney 
Mick Kelly  Geoff Martin
Bob Carnie  Phil Jacobson
John Ferguson George Yacoub
Steve Hill  A. Davidson
Tony McKenzie  

With major questions marks around the depth of the Roosters squad it was thought Easts wouldn’t be able to overcome a series of injuries (and suspensions) that would lead to the regular unavailability of quality players. 

However, they did suffer many weeks without their best players and were forced to use 36 players in First Grade throughout 1975. 1974 Premiership players Ken Jones missed 16 matches, Greg Bandiera (11), Russell Fairfax (6), Ian Mackay (6), Bill Mullins (5), Arthur Beetson (5) and Mark Harris (5). Premiership lock Kevin Stevens missed 7 matches and high profile recruit Dennis Tutty, a former Australian international, missed 8 games.

When Grand Final day arrived, the Roosters had lost the services of Harris (leg), Fairfax (leg), Jones (arm), Bandiera (hand) and Tutty (arm). Further, club stalwart and 1974 Premiership winner Bunny Reilly carried a knee injury into the decider and only played the final nine minutes off the bench, as a gesture from Gibson, whilst Reg Clough, who replaced the injured John Brass for the Preliminary Final the week before, broke his ankle in that match, his only appearance in first grade. 

So, the Grand Final was won, by a record score, by a team missing six players and a roster ripped apart by the 13 Import Rule. 50 years later it still seems hard to believe. 

Standing: Elwyn Walters, Grant Hedger, Ian Mackay, Ron Coote, Bill Mullins, Arthur Beetson (Captain), Des O’Reilly, Ian Schubert, Barry ‘Bunny’ Reilly 

Kneeling: John Rheinberger, John Brass, Kevin Stevens, Bruce Pickett, Johnny Mayes, John Peard 

The Club Championship win was even more remarkable. The Under 23s finished fourth in the regular season and the Reserve Grade team finished third. Off the back of a record 19 consecutive wins the First Grade team finished the season on 40 points, 10 clear of second placed Manly-Warringah. 

1975 NSWRL Under 23s Premiership Table

Club Played Won Drew Lost For Against Points
Cronulla-Sutherland 22 16 2 4 390 218 34
Canterbury-Bankstown 22 16 1 5 419 257 33
Balmain  22 13 1 8 342 236 27
Eastern Suburbs *  22 13 1 8 348 258 27
Parramatta  22 11 5 6 343 299 27
Penrith  22 12 2 8 347 299 26
South Sydney  22 11 2 9 320 349 24
St George  22 10 2 10 282 298 22
Western Suburbs  22 9 1 12 286 318 19
Manly-Warringah 22 8   14 291 276 16
Newtown  22 4   18 182 438 8
North Sydney 22   1 21 166 470 1

^ Cronulla-Sutherland (1st) defeated Balmain (3rd) in the 1975 NSWRL Under 23s Grand Final 20 - 8 
* Eastern Suburbs (4th) defeated Parramatta (5th) in the Minor Qualifying Semi Final 28 - 9 before 
losing the next week to Canterbury-Bankstown (2nd) in the Minor Semi Final 26 - 5 

1975 NSWRL Reserve Grade Premiership Table 

Club Played Won Drew Lost For Against Points
Parramatta ^ 22 16 3 3 456 246 35
Manly-Warringah 22  15 2 5 380 223 32
Eastern Suburbs * 22  14 1 7 292 214 29
Cronulla-Sutherland 22  13 2 7 399 284 28
Canterbury-Bankstown 22  13 1 8 306 269 27
St George  22  12 1 9 297 237 25
South Sydney  22  10 1 11 286 318 21
Balmain  22  10 1 11 256 388 21
Western Suburbs 22  9 1 12 295 292 19
Newtown  22  4 2 16 210 314 10
North Sydney  22  4 2 16 277 428 10
Penrith  22  3 1 18 202 443 7

^ Parramatta (1st) defeated Cronulla-Sutherland (4th) in the 1975 NSWRL Reserve Grade Grand Final 21 - 13 
* Eastern Suburbs (3rd) lost to Cronulla-Sutherland (4th) in the Minor Semi Final 23 - 2 after 
losing the previous week to Manly-Warringah (2nd) in the Major Qualifying Final 17 - 8 

1975 NSWRL First Grade Premiership Table 

Club Played Won Drew Lost For Against Points
Eastern Suburbs ^ 22  20   2 431 198 40
Manly-Warringah  22  15   7 439 314 30
St George  22  12 2 8 341 294 26
Canterbury-Bankstown 22  11 2 9 330 287 24
Western Suburbs *  22  10 1 11 365 289 21
Parramatta #  22  10 1 11 391 373 21
Balmain  22  10 1 11 288 357 21
Cronulla-Sutherland  22  9 1 12 370 375 19
North Sydney  22  9   13 322 414 18
Newtown  22  7 2 13 349 422 16
Penrith  22  7 1 14 312 452 15
South Sydney  22  6   16 298 461 12

^ Eastern Suburbs (1st) defeated St George (3rd) in The 1975 NSWRL First Grade Grand Final 38 - 0 
* Western Suburbs deducted one competition point for using an illegal replacement player (Mick Liubinskas) in Round 15 
# Parramatta defeated Western Suburbs and Balmain in mid-week play-offs to qualify for the 1975 semi finals in fifth place 

1975 NSWRL Club Championship Table 

First Grade points multiplied by 4, Reserve Grade by 3, Under 23s by 2 

Club First Grade Reserves Under 23s Points
Eastern Suburbs 160 87 54 301
Manly-Warringah 120 96 32 248
Canterbury-Bankstown 96 81 66 243
Parramatta  84 105 54 243
Cronulla-Sutherland  76 84 68 228
St George  104 75 44 223
Balmain  84 63 54 201
Western Suburbs  84 57 38 179
South Sydney  48 63 48 159
Penrith  60 21 52 133
Newtown  64 30 16 110
North Sydney  72 30 2 104

The 53-point winning margin on the Club Championship table was just 10 points shy of the 311 points accrued when the Roosters won the 1974 Club Championship. It was an extraordinary testimony to the Easts coaching staff and the 66 players who represented the Roosters in 1975. An unforgettable year that was simply the best! 

Acknowledgement of Country

Sydney Roosters respect and honour the Traditional Custodians of the land and pay our respects to their Elders past, present and future. We acknowledge the stories, traditions and living cultures of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples on the lands we meet, gather and play on.